Both have been phenomenal. They implanted spiritual beliefs in both the East and the West to the modern society - a breakaway from the regular spiritual garbage heaps. You could argue that Carlos Castaneda wasn't as spiritual. Well, that depends on your definition of spirituality.
His life or the controversies that later arose gave us different pictures. But he was honest. He was at least honest that he didn't portray himself as a man with a squeaky-clean heart. He portrayed himself with the limitations of a 1960's American who was more material than the Yaqui Indian he met.
I began with Robert Svoboda though with
Aghora (Product/Book links are Affiliate links) I, II and III. He literally made me run for my life with me losing even my basic subsistence. Part of the Karma goes to him while I retain the other part to myself. I also believe that all he has incurred through me are good karmas. There is a reason for this that I will come back to later.
Is Carlos Castaneda's Don Juan real? Is Robert Svoboda's Vimalananda in Aghora real?
If Carlos Castaneda's Don Juan is real depends on what you are looking at. As Robert Svoboda had said, in one of his books, subjective reality is more real than objective reality, as objective reality is transient. We don't live longer than 120 years in most cases. We are just a mere speck in the macrocosm.
I do not also know if Carlos and Robert Svoboda had been friends or if Carlos inspired Robert Svoboda. I can strongly believe that they met with similar fates. In
Aghora II, as well, the one who has written the foreword has expressed doubts on Vimalananda's existence or reality. And once, Robert Svoboda expressed shock over such disbelief in one of his articles.
Don Juan could be a pseudonym or a changed name whether or not Carlos Castaneda mentioned it. I also believe that such amount of wisdom is not possible for an individual as Carlos. He also rightly expresses his moods and reactions to
Don Juan's teachings. He would have strained himself a huge deal, if he had written it all by himself or through research alone. I think such neat works of his could not have been possible without a man as Don Juan.
Well, if that sounds a bit amateurish on my part, I would say that it is relatively easy to come across such people. I have easily seen people who have nature at their behest or to whom it is very close to and who live in harmony with nature. Perhaps, it is so alien to the West that has changed perception to believe (only) in proof. Simply put, things exist without proof.
I do not also find the arguments against Don Juan's existence convincing. Their reliance on dates, CC's whereabouts, alibi, etc. make little sense. What if he was deliberate with the dates? What if he deliberately concealed the identity of Don Juan? Such people don't like to be seen, I know. Not everyone walks the red carpet, smiles and waves in front of the camera in Cannes or give you Presidential address. Those are not the only realities because we see them.
Although not culture-specific, Don Juan's teachings can come from a man so woven into some culture. Not by someone who flips through at the library. Even if Carlos Castaneda did so, I would only think that, of course, I want to learn more about Robert Svoboda's and Carlos Castaneda's works after reading them both in full.
I can also ask a lot of natives about it and learn further but I would also be aware that such knowledge or wisdom is not possible for all in a culture. Vimalananda is not possible at every turn of Mumbai. You would see more of Mercs and Audis in Mumbai than Vimalanandas. It's a place of money and pleasures than about Vimalanandas, (as mentioned in Aghora itself).
A Look into Aghora and Vimalananda
I feel a bit of a blasphemy analyzing Vimalananda's existence for he (or Robert Svoboda) has literally shown me a different world where I now live. To me, Vimalananda is a person who will exist throughout my life in me. He made his wisdom so profound that I immediately latched onto it.
It was actually no different because I was used to mythology through my mother and grandparents who so rightly interpreted them for me. Robert Svoboda, Vimalananda or Aghora didn't feel any strange for me to have me feel that they were lying anywhere. Some of Kinaram's myths, other popular myths have been swept into Aghora goes one of the observations.
When I read the book, I did know that. I was taken aback by the profound meanings and wisdom with which the stories were told. It was the interpretation by Vimalananda that made me fall in love with them than the myths or stories themselves. As I completed the first book, I was so renewed. I disentangled myself from the Maya which had woven around me so much.
The second and the third were profound sources of wisdom too. The second deals with Vimalananda's teachings, the teacher and the taught. Here, we do get to learn more from an actual source of wisdom. You can find the wisdom through their discussions as well as the events that take place. The third goes much further in bringing you wisdom from the daily life of Aghori Vimalananda with Robert Svoboda.
It started slowly and I was tired of reading about horses until it hit me bang like Kundalini itself. Of course, it is not that easy to even mention the experience. I know how such kind of modern/contemporary seers help people with things. I have known a few in my childhood but now I don't know where they are.
They looked just like ordinary men than holy men. I would be lucky if I found one, when I actually understand their doings. The
third part of Aghora, the Law of Karma, is the most realistic, as it also talks in depth about the karma involved between people and relationships.
More than if Vimalananda is real, the book, the events, experiences, the message, wisdom, the change it causes to your life, etc. are real. And Vimalananda is real too, as some people have accounted for his existence. There are real living people who knew Vimalananda. I have a mentor too. I do not unnecessarily talk about him or let people know that I know him. Nor would he like it. So, as I keep it a secret, it does not become any less real because time does erase everyone's existence.
The Conclusion
I am just thankful to both Carlos Castaneda and Robert Svoboda or should I say Robert Svoboda (as he still lives his good stead) and Carlos Castaneda because of the profound wisdom that they have filled me with. I now understand the purpose of my soul (if it in fact has one). I now understand what I need to do. I would have been blind to the "real" world without these two great Americans.
Many Americans quite gullible enough tend to fall into cults which is more of their mistake than those who founded the cults. And Don Juan didn't give Carlos Castaneda the wisdom and nobility that Vimalananda gave Robert Svoboda. The former could have given but Carlos could have been selective. I don't attach the teachings of these four great men to their personality or their individual selves. I leave it to my capacity to interpret them as best as I can and take the best out of them.
Those who criticized both the authors and their mentors were actually insecure of their own lives, which I can see even in their posts and comments on many forums. They did not even adequately understand themselves nor their lives to actually criticize both Robert Svoboda and Carlos Castaneda. Both of them are keys to forgotten wisdom.
I cannot even interpret a deity's form in my 26 years of life in India, since my birth. Robert Svoboda does it for me. He is a great source of wisdom and I understand his language. He explains every little detail about Gods and Goddesses of India. It's a great tradition for us humans that of the likes of Carl Jung, Robert Svoboda and Carlos Castaneda. I know there are many other.
Just take a shift in your perception to see how different the world is from the mistaken interpretation of the world by our senses. We have put all our irrational emotions into interpreting the world. That shift in the perception can keep you eternally happy and will help you understand life as it is, even if you are stripped to the bone.
To transcend fear is the path of Aghora and so does Don Juan teach the same to Carlos Castaneda. Fear is an illusion and we believe illusion is real. To have your worst of illusions removed is the best thing that can happen in your life. Time and again, all religions and cultures have been echoing this one truth to all of us. These four men brought it out very clearly, in a language that we understand.
It is time for us to understand this and move on with our lives to further unraveling of truth than to use our limited intellects to guide us into questioning truths. A particle observed can change its path when observed. So, reality is multidimensional than the three dimensional reality we live in. We are a sort of flatlanders. We need to pop out and understand our existence and live every moment of our life with sheer and real joy!
Both the Aghora series (of Vimalananda) and Carlos Castaneda's books (of Don Juan) help you transcend and gain huge wisdom! I salute these men!